Is It More Sustainable to Shop Local?

“Shop local” has become a rallying cry for conscious consumers. It is a way to vote with your wallet, reduce environmental harm, and support your community. But is it always the more sustainable choice?

Here is a grounded, practical look at what makes local shopping sustainable and what does not.

‍

The Pros of Shopping Local

‍

1. Slows down impulse purchases

‍

Local shopping takes more intention. You have to plan your errands, carve out time, and physically go somewhere. This built-in friction can be a good thing because it creates fewer late-night impulse buys and fewer “just because” purchases.

‍

2. Keeps your money in the local economy

‍

When you buy from a locally owned shop, your money stays within your community instead of going to massive big box stores or e-commerce platforms. This strengthens small businesses, supports local jobs, and keeps your area more economically resilient.

‍

3. Roots you in your community

‍

Shopping local gets you out of your house and into your neighbourhood. At a hardware store, you might run into someone buying seeds for a community garden. In a bookstore, you may discover a writing club or an author event. These micro-interactions build connection, which is deeply intertwined with sustainable living.

‍

4. Reduces returns and associated carbon costs

‍

In-store shopping lets you see the true size, colour, texture, and quality of an item. This makes you less likely to return it. Returns have a massive carbon footprint because items must be shipped back, reprocessed, or sometimes even landfilled. Fewer returns means less shipping, less waste, and fewer emissions.

‍

5. Indirectly supports local causes

‍

Independent thrift shops frequently donate profits to neighbouhood organizations, shelters, and community programs. Bigger chains do not always do that. So your purchase can support both circular fashion and local causes.

‍

The Cons of Shopping Local

‍

1. You may burn more fuel running errands

Individual car trips can sometimes generate more emissions than an optimised delivery truck making many stops on a route. If you drive store to store, local shopping can have a bigger carbon footprint than delivery, especially in car-dependent cities. To mitigate this, take public transit or walk when you can. When you have to drive, choose the most important route. You can even ask a friend to tag along to consolidate trips!

‍

2. Local stores do not always stock sustainable brands

‍

A shop may be locally owned, but the products on the shelves are not necessarily sustainable. Many small stores carry the same global brands as big retailers. Use the Commons app to search brands in store. And if there’s a sustainable brand you’d like to see on the shelf, let the shop know! Another perk of shopping local is you can talk directly to the folks who stock the store.

‍

3. Small stores cannot always afford sustainable infrastructure

‍

Big companies can invest in renewable energy, low-waste packaging systems, bulk supply chains, and efficient logistics. A small boutique may want to be sustainable but may not have the budget or freedom to implement large-scale changes.

‍

So, Is Shopping Local More Sustainable?

‍

Not automatically. But it can be, especially when it shifts your behavior in meaningful ways:

‍

• Shop local when you can, especially for books, gifts, produce, niche items, and anything you want to take your time choosing.
• Use local shopping to slow down consumption so your purchases become more considered and less impulsive.
• Pair local shopping with walking, biking, or public transit whenever possible.
• Treat local shopping as community-building rather than only consumption.

‍

Local shopping is not a silver bullet for sustainability. But it is a powerful tool that reduces mindless buying, connects you with your community, and encourages a slower, more thoughtful relationship with consumption.